You know my answer's gonna include the word 'Oliva', although there are lots and lots of maduros I like.
By the way Mr.Eric "Why don't we talk more cigar talk" B., you put this post in the "New Member Introductions" section! I couldn't care less, just sayin'...:D
Actually the thread's been magically moved. Oh, here's another maduro I like, kinda surprising: Gispert. It's a way different smoke than their natural, at least for me. I could do without the box press, but it seems to round out in shape as it's smoked.
I can't pick one because I have become a sungrown junkie but here is my go to list in no particular order:
Perdomo Reserve Maduro
Camacho SLR Maduro
601 Oscuro
Don Pepin Blue Label
Padron 1964 Maduro
Perdomo ESV 1991 Maduro